I Can't Give You Anything But Love

  • The Song
  • Back Stories
composition date
1928
genre
Show
songwriter(s)
Dorothy Fields
Jimmy McHugh
related performer(s)
Ethel Waters
Lena Horne

Who wrote the tune?

Jimmy McHugh and Dorothy Fields were reportedly outside Tiffany’s jewelry store when they heard a swain tell his girlfriend, “I Can’t Give You Anything But Love.” They took the phrase, added “Lindy” (referring to Charles Lindburgh) and wrote a song. Perhaps realizing that the addition would date the song, they replaced the name with “baby.” Or maybe not. Fats Waller claimed he wrote the tune and sold it to Jimmy McHugh, along with “On the Sunny Side of the Street.” We do know that later, when Fields wrote additional lyrics for the film remake of Roberta, titled Lovely to Look At, she kept McHugh’s name as co-author on the songs although he had nothing to do with writing them.

Bookmark and Share
The 3 part PBS Series
Own the DVD